A simple two-step approach involving rubber modification and cross-linking yields fully reworkable, elastic rubber products.
A method for using Diels Alder thermo-reversible chemistry as cross-linking tool for rubber products is demonstrated. In this work, a commercial ethylene-propylene rubber, grafted with maleic anhydride, is thermo-reversibly cross-linked in two steps. The pending anhydride moieties are first modified with furfurylamine to graft furan groups to the rubber backbone. These pendant furan groups are then cross-linked with a bis-maleimide via a Diels-Alder coupling reaction. Both reactions can be performed under a broad range of experimental conditions and can easily be applied on a large scale. The material properties of the resulting Diels-Alder cross-linked rubbers are similar to a peroxide-cured ethylene/propylene/diene rubber (EPDM) reference. The cross-links break at elevated temperatures (> 150 °C) via the retro-Diels-Alder reaction and can be reformed by thermal annealing at lower temperatures (50-70 °C). Reversibility of the system was proven with infrared spectroscopy, solubility tests and mechanical properties. Recyclability of the material was also shown in a practical way, i.e., by cutting a cross-linked sample into small parts and compression molding them into new samples displaying comparable mechanical properties, which is not possible for conventionally cross-linked rubbers.
Sulfur vulcanization and peroxide curing are currently the main industrial cross-linking techniques in the rubber industry, yielding irreversible chemical cross-links that prevent melt reprocessing.1, 2 A 'cradle to cradle' approach to recycle cross-linked rubbers requires a material that behaves similar to permanently cross-linked rubbers at service conditions, while having the processability and complete recyclability of a thermoplastic at high temperatures. An approach to achieve such recyclability uses rubbery networks with reversible cross-links that respond to an external stimulus, such as temperature (most feasible from the viewpoint of future industrial applications).3-5 The formation of these cross-links at relatively low service temperatures is required for good mechanical behavior of the rubber, while their cleavage at high temperatures (similar to processing temperature of original non-cross-linked compound) allows for recycling of the material.
Some specific materials can be reversibly cross-linked by making use of so-called dynamic covalent networks via polycondensation reactions6 or by so-called reversible network topology freezing via transesterification reactions.7-9 The disadvantage of these approaches is the necessity of designing and synthesizing new polymers rather than modifying existing, commercial rubbers that already have the desired properties. Techniques to thermo-reversibly cross-link rubbers involve hydrogen bonding, ionic interactions and covalent bonding such as via thermo-activated disulfide rearrangements.10-13 Recently, thermo-reversible cross-linking via Diels-Alder (DA) chemistry was developed.14-21 DA chemistry can be applied to a broad range of polymers and represents a popular choice, especially since the DA reaction allows for relatively fast kinetics and mild reaction conditions.17, 22-24 Their low coupling and high decoupling temperatures make furan and maleimide excellent candidates for reversible polymer cross-linking.18-20, 25-28
The aim of the present work is to provide a method for the use of DA chemistry as a thermo-reversible cross-linking tool for an industrial rubber product (Figure 1).5 First, the reactivity of saturated hydrocarbon elastomers, such as ethylene/propylene rubbers (EPM), has to be increased. A commercially relevant example that facilitates this is the peroxide-initiated free-radical grafting of maleic anhydride (MA).29-34 Secondly, a furan group can be grafted onto such a maleated EPM rubber by inserting furfurylamine (FFA) into the pendant anhydride to form an imide.35, 36 Finally, the furan moieties that are thus attached to the rubber backbone can then participate in thermo-reversible DA chemistry as an electron-rich diene.25, 37 The electron-poor bis-maleimide (BM) is a suitable dienophile for this cross-linking reaction.19, 26, 38
Figure 1. Reaction scheme. Furan grafting and bismaleimide cross-linking of EPM-g-MA rubber (reprinted with permission from 5). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
1. Rubber Modification
2. Diels-Alder Cross-linking and Reprocessing
3. Peroxide and Sulfur Curing of ENB-EPDM
4. Cross-link Density Determination
The successful modification of EPM-g-MA into EPM-g-furan and the cross-linking with the bismaleimide is shown by Fourier transform infrared spectrometry (FTIR) (Figure 2). The presence of furan groups in the EPM-g-furan product can be deduced from the splitting of the CC aliphatic stretching peak ( = 1,050 cm-1) into two furan peaks (
= 1,073 cm-1 and
= 1,013 cm-1), the appearance of the C=C furan stretching vibration (
= 1,504 cm-1) and of the deformation vibration at 599 cm-1.15, 37, 37 The furan ring stretching peaks at 1,436 and 1,345 cm-1 cannot not be observed as they are hidden by the large overlapping CH2-vibrations of the rubber backbone at 1,450 cm-1 and 1,350 cm-1.15 The incorporation of the BM can be deduced from the appearance of
at 1,190 cm-1 and of the characteristic succinimide bands (
= 1,385 cm-1,
= 1,311 cm-1 and
= 620 cm-1).45, 46 The furan-related absorption (
) decreases upon cross-linking and the
carbonyl band increases as a result of a second absorption around 1,770 cm-1 that is attributed to the succinimide ring resulting from the cycloaddition.25
FTIR and elemental analysis were used to determine the modification and cross-linking conversions (Table 1). The FT-IR and EA conversions were used to determine the cross-link density of the DA cross-linked EPM-g-furan, which was found to be 1.8 x 10-4 ± 3 x 10-5 mol/cm3. According to swell tests (protocol 4), the gel content of all cross-linked samples was approximately 100% and the cross-link density of the DA cross-linked EPM-g-furan was 2.1 x 10-4 ± 2 x 10-5 mol/cm3. The cross-link densities of the sulfur- and peroxide-cured EPDM reference systems were found to be respectively 1.7 x 10-4 ± 6 x 10-6 and 1.8 x 10-4 ± 8 x 10-6 mol/cm3, respectively.
Figure 2. FT-IR absorption spectra. Spectra of left: EPM-g-MA (red) and modified EPM-g-furan (black) and right: of the non-cross-linked EPM-g-furan (black) and the Diels-Alder cross-linked EPM-g-furan (blue) (reprinted with permission from 5). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
wt% N | wt% C | wt% H | FT-IR conversion (%) | EA conversion (%) | |
EPM-g-MA | < 0.01 | 84.7 | 14.3 | – | |
EPM-g-furan | 0.3 | 84.8 | 14.2 | 96 | 93 |
DA cross-linked EPM-g-furan | 0.4 | 84.2 | 14 | 72 | 80 |
Table 1. Reaction conversions. Results from Elemental Analysis and FT-IR (adapted with permission from 5).
The de-cross-linking of the DA cross-linked EPM-g-furan product was followed by transmission FT-IR (Figure 3). Some characteristic furan peaks such as and at respectively 1,504 and 1,013 cm-1 decrease upon thermal annealing at 50 °C and increases after compression molding at 175 °C. This indicates that cross-linking and de-cross-linking takes place via a reversible DA reaction between the grafted furan groups and the added BM cross-linking agents.47 Solubility tests are a more practical method to observe the effects of cross-linking and de-cross-linking. EPM-g-furan is soluble in decalin (5 wt%) at 23 °C. The same material cross-linked with BM is clearly insoluble under the same conditions. Thermo-reversibility of the cross-linking reaction was shown by dissolving the product during 1 hour of heating to 175 °C. Finally, a practical way of testing the material's reworkability is by grinding or cutting the cross-linked rubber and compression molding it at 160 °C and 100 bar for 30 minutes. The resulting reprocessed material was found to have a cross-link density of 2.0 x 10-4 ± 2 x 10-5 mol/cm3. When an EPDM rubber is irreversibly cross-linked with peroxide, remolding the cut pieces under the same conditions does not yield a coherent sample (Figure 4).
Figure 3. FT-IR absorption spectra. Spectra of EPM-g-furan and DA (de/re-)cross-linked EPM-g-furan (reprinted with permission from 5). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4. Reprocessing rubber samples. Sample bars of thermoreversibly cross-linked and sulphur- and peroxide-cured rubbers that are all reprocessed under the same conditions. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
The hardness increases and the compression set decreases when going from the non-cross-linked EPM-g-MA and EPM-g-furan precursors to the DA cross-linked EPM-g-furan (Figure 5). This clearly indicates the conversion of the viscous polymer into an elastic network that occurs upon cross-linking. The hardness and compression set of reprocessed samples of respectively 44 Shore A and 5% are comparable to those of the original DA cross-linked samples. The hardness and compression set of the sulfur and peroxide cross-linked EPDM rubbers were 60 and 61 Shore A and 5% and 8% respectively. Although these irreversibly cross-linked samples have higher hardness values, their compression set is slightly inferior to the DA cross-linked samples.
The elongation at break decreases when going from the non-cross-linked EPM-g-MA to the modified EPM-g-furan (Figure 6). This difference could be explained by synergetic effects of the pending, conjugated furan groups.48 Their increased rigidity, π-stacking stabilization and a very low degree of radical cross-linking between the furans could be enough to decrease the rubber's elasticity to a certain extent. The cross-linked EPM-g-furan samples show significantly higher tensile moduli and lower elongation at break values compared to their non-cross-linked precursors. These high tensile moduli and low elongation are indicative for cross-linked rubbers.49, 50 It also appears that the recycled cross-linked rubbers retain these characteristic properties of cross-linked rubbers, indicating that these cross-linked rubbers can be reshaped or reworked, regardless of their high modulus and low elongation. The median stress-strain curves also show that the thermo-reversibly, DA cross-linked rubber, before and after reprocessing, yields at higher stresses and lower strains than their non-cross-linked EPM-g-MA and EPM-g-furan precursors. This distinction is illustrative for the different behavior of cross-linked and non-cross-linked rubbers as is illustrated by the peroxide and sulfur cured EPDM samples.51, 52 These peroxide and sulfur cured reference samples appear to have slightly higher Young's moduli than the DA cross-linked rubbers even though they were measured to have similar cross-link densities. The tensile strength and elongation at break of the DA cross-linked samples however, are at least as good as those of the peroxide and sulfur cured samples.
Figure 5. Hardness and compression set. Results for non-cross-linked EPM-g-MA and EPM-g-furan, DA cross-linked EPM-g-furan and irreversibly sulfur- and peroxide-cured EPDM rubbers. Error bars represent the standard deviations (reprinted with permission from 5). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6. Tensile test. Results for EPM-g-MA (1), EPM-g-furan (2), DA cross-linked EPM-g-furan (3) and reprocessed, DA cross-linked EPM-g-furan (4) together with sulfur- (5) and peroxide- (6) cured EPDM. Median stress-strain graphs (left) and the corresponding Young's modulus, tensile strength and elongation at break (right). Error bars represent the standard deviations. (Reprinted with permission from 5) Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
A commercial EPM-g-MA rubber was thermo-reversibly cross-linked in a simple two-step approach. The maleated rubber was first modified with FFA to graft furan groups onto the rubber backbone. The resulting pending furans show reactivity as Diels-Alder dienes. An aliphatic BM was used as cross-linking agent, resulting in a thermo-reversible bridge between two furan moieties. Both reactions were successful with good conversions (> 80%) according to infrared spectroscopy, elemental analysis. Cross-linking was shown by swelling and solubility tests, yielding a gel content of 100%.
For the successful execution of the protocol described, it is critical that the individual components are carefully prepared. Unfortunately, the preparation of reworkable rubbers by making use of the method described here does not allow for easy upscaling to larger quantities. Although no other methods of preparing this reworkable rubber product have been described in the open literature, an analogy with the well-known free-radical grafting of maleic anhydride onto EPM rubber can be drawn in this respect.32 Melt modification of the rubber is a promising alternative that does not require a solvent, intermediate purification or drying steps and can be executed on commercial equipment such as melt mixers or extruders. The production of such a reworkable rubber would be much more time and cost efficient if it were to be executed via melt processing. On the other hand, the method described allows for more control of the reaction and a more well-defined end-product.
On a more general level of comparison between the current approach towards reworkable rubbers and other recycling approaches (e.g., devulcanization), it must be noted that the materials have to be modified prior to cross-linking and that the formed cross-links fail at relatively low temperatures (> 180%). Nevertheless, this approach does allow for the production of a "cradle-to-cradle" recyclable rubber product whereas the recyclability of devulcanized rubbers is severely limited up to the reuse of few percentages in combination with virgin components.54, 55
The cross-link densities of the DA cross-linked EPM-g-furan as determined from FT-IR and EA correspond to those determined from swell tests. The resulting values are characteristic for loosely cross-linked, rubbery networks and correspond to the typical cross-link densities of sulfur and peroxide cured EPDM gums (1-5 x 10-4 mol/cm3) reported in literature.53, 54 The cross-link density of the DA cross-linked samples is comparable to those of sulfur- and peroxide-cured EPDM references, allowing for a comparison of properties.
Finally, the Shore A hardness, Young´s modulus, elongation at break, ultimate tensile strength and compression set all indicate the transformation of a viscous polymer into an elastic rubber network upon the addition of BM. These mechanical properties correspond to those of sulphur- and peroxide-cured references samples and they were retained after reprocessing the thermo-reversibly cross-linked rubber. Reprocessing of the material was performed for up to 5 times without any significant loss of properties.
The presented results provide a new route for the (reversible) cross-linking of (EPM) rubbers via a (retro)Diels-Alder reaction, which complements the toolbox of rubber recycling. They pave the way towards the application of such cross-linking strategies (and the recyclability these might entail) for a variety of rubber products.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This research forms part of the research program of the Dutch Polymer Institute, project #749.
ENB-EPDM | LANXESS Elastomers B.V. | Keltan 8550C | |
EPM-g-MA | LANXESS Elastomers B.V. | Keltan DE5005 | Vacuum oven for one hour at 175 °C |
furfurylamine | Sigma-Aldrich | F20009 | Freshly distillated before use |
di-dodecylamine | Sigma-Aldrich | 36784 | |
maleic anhydride | Sigma-Aldrich | M0357 | |
octadecyl-1-(3,5-di-tert.-butyl-4-hydroxyphenyl)propionate | Sigma-Aldrich | 367079 | |
bis(tert.-butylperoxy-iso-propyl) benzene | Sigma-Aldrich | 531685 | |
tetrahydrofuran | Sigma-Aldrich | 401757 | |
decalin | Sigma-Aldrich | 294772 | |
acetone | Sigma-Aldrich | 320110 |