The complexes were prepared based on established procedures18,28 and their purity may be evaluated by NMR and elemental analysis.
The data received from the MTT assay is analyzed to evaluate the cytotoxicity of the compound18,21. First, subtraction of the blank control absorbance value from all the other values is performed. Second, the THF solvent control value is set to 100% viability, as no growth inhibiting compound was added. All other values are transformed into percentage of viability according to the control. The concentrations applied and the relative viability percentage calculated are then inserted into the GraphPad Prism software (or equivalent) to determine the IC50 values based on a nonlinear regression of a variable slope (four parameters) model (Figure 4, Table 1)29.
The measurements should be performed on a range of concentrations that will produce a graph displaying an even point distribution: at least three points on each plateau and three points to define the slope (Figure 3, graph A). Insufficient measurements at high concentrations or low concentrations (Figure 3, graph B) will impair the nonlinear regression fit of the curve required for determination of IC50 values, and as a result, diminish their accuracy.
Relative IC50 values, as determined by the nonlinear regression fit29, correspond to the concentrations leading to 50% of the cell growth inhibition possible by the compound tested, which is calculated as the middle point between the maximal and minimal cell viability measured (not necessarily 100% and 0%, respectively, see Figure 3, graph C, a). For instance, if a compound inhibits only 60% of cell growth relative to the control (and 0% at low concentrations), its relative IC50 is the concentration leading to 30% inhibition relative to the control. The error values should reflect the deviation of the results obtained for different repetitions from the average IC50 value reported, taken as the STDs. In addition, maximal cell growth inhibition (%) values should be reported, as calculated by subtracting from 100% the minimal viability measured.
An alternative analysis may include determination of absolute IC50 values. These correspond to the concentrations leading to 50% cell growth inhibition relative to the 100% control, regardless of the maximal and minimal cell viability measured. Such values can also be derived by a non-linear regression model. As these values are absolute, reporting the maximal cell growth inhibition values is optional. As depicted in Figure 3, graph C, a compound may have a relatively low activity in terms of maximal cell growth inhibition properties (curve a), and still exhibit a relative IC50 value that is lower not only than its absolute one, but also than that of a compound that reaches close to 100% growth inhibition (curve b). It is thus extremely valuable to present the curve along with the reported IC50 values of any kind.
When inspecting the results of the experiments described in the protocol (Figure 4, Table 1), it is clear that cisplatin and complexes LTi(OiPr)2 and VO(OiPr) are highly active. It is also noticeable that the closer the maximal inhibition value of a given compound is to 100%, the closer the relative IC50 value is to the absolute one. When comparing the IC50 values among the different compounds, the Ti (IV) complex has the highest cytotoxicity and its IC50 values are lower than those of cisplatin and the V (V) complex. However, the free ligand exhibits markedly reduced activity, since following addition of the ligand at different concentrations, the cell viability does not drop as significantly as it does for its complexes. This assures that the high anticancer activity of the complexes relies on the metal centers. Since the free ligand barely reaches 50% cell growth inhibition, an absolute IC50 value cannot be accurately derived. In fact, a relative value also could not have been adequately calculated by the software due to the minor activity and corresponding high error values. Nevertheless, it is clear that even if a relative IC50 value could have been derived for H2L, it would not have reflected an appreciable activity, thus rendering the report of the maximal inhibition value along with relative IC50 values (and the depiction of the curve) essential.
Relative IC50 (μM) | Absolute IC50 (μM) | Maximal inhibition (%) | |
LVO(OiPr) | 13±3 | 19±8 | 81% |
LTi(OiPr)2 | 3±1 | 5±3 | 87% |
H2L | – | – | 47% |
Cisplatin | 14±5 | 13±6 | 91% |
Table 1. Cytotoxicity results for the compounds tested: Relative and absolute IC50 (μM) and maximum cell growth inhibition values toward HT-29 cells following an incubation period of three days with the V (V) complex LVO(OiPr), Ti (IV) complex LTi(OiPr)2, the free ligand H2L and cisplatin;18,21 IC50 values are given as average of at least three times three repetitions with error values as the STDs.
Figure 1. The reduction of MTT by mitochondrial and cytosolic enzymes to formazan. Click here to view larger figure.
Figure 2. Preparation of V (V) and Ti (IV) complexes18,28. Click here to view larger figure.
Figure 3. Examples of results of cell viability measurements. Click here to view larger figure.
Figure 4. Dose dependent cytotoxicity curves for the compounds tested: Dependence of HT-29 cell viability on administered concentration of the V (V) complex LVO(OiPr) (blue), the Ti (IV) complex LTi(OiPr)2 (red), free ligand H2L (black) and cisplatin (green), following an incubation period of three days, as obtained from at least three times three repetitions as reflected by the error values18,21.
Reagent/Material | |||
Fetal bovine serum (FBS) | Biological Industries | 04-007-1A | |
Hexane AR | Gadot | 830122313 | Dried using a solvent drying system |
HT-29 cell line | ATCC | HTB-38 | |
Isopropanol AR | Gadot | 830111370 | |
L-glutamine | Biological Industries | 03-020-1B | |
MTT | Sigma-Aldrich | M5655-1G | |
Penicillin/streptomycin antibiotics | Biological Industries | 03-031-1B | |
RPMI-1640 with phenol red with L-glutamine | Sigma-Aldrich | R8758 | |
RPMI without phenol red | Biological Industries | 01-103-1A | |
Tetrahydrofuran (THF) AR | Gadot | 830156391 | dried using a solvent drying system |
Ti(OiPr)4 | Sigma-Aldrich | 205273-500ML | moisture sensitive |
Trypsin/EDTA | Biological Industries | 03-052-1B | |
VO(OiPr)3 | Sigma-Aldrich | 404926-10G | moisture sensitive |
Equipment | |||
12-channel pipette 30-300 μl | Thermo Scientific | ||
12-channel pipette 5-50 μl | Finnpipette | ||
75 cm2 flask | NUNC | 156472 | |
96-well plate with lid (flat bottom) | NUNC | 167008 | |
CO2 Incubator | Binder | APT.line C150 | |
Counter chamber | Marienfeld-Superior | 650030 | |
Eppendorf vial | KARTELL | ||
Glove box | M. Braun | ||
Laminar flow hood | ADS LAMINAIRE | OPTIMALE 12 | |
Microplate reader spectrophotometer | Bio-Tek | El-800 | |
Microscope | Nikon | Eclipse TS100 | |
Pipette 20-200 μl | Finnpipette | ||
Pipette 5-50 μl | Finnpipette |
Titanium (IV) and vanadium (V) complexes are highly potent anticancer agents. A challenge in their synthesis refers to their hydrolytic instability; therefore their preparation should be conducted under an inert atmosphere. Evaluation of the anticancer activity of these complexes can be achieved by the MTT assay.
The MTT assay is a colorimetric viability assay based on enzymatic reduction of the MTT molecule to formazan when it is exposed to viable cells. The outcome of the reduction is a color change of the MTT molecule. Absorbance measurements relative to a control determine the percentage of remaining viable cancer cells following their treatment with varying concentrations of a tested compound, which is translated to the compound anticancer activity and its IC50 values. The MTT assay is widely common in cytotoxicity studies due to its accuracy, rapidity, and relative simplicity.
Herein we present a detailed protocol for the synthesis of air sensitive metal based drugs and cell viability measurements, including preparation of the cell plates, incubation of the compounds with the cells, viability measurements using the MTT assay, and determination of IC50 values.
Titanium (IV) and vanadium (V) complexes are highly potent anticancer agents. A challenge in their synthesis refers to their hydrolytic instability; therefore their preparation should be conducted under an inert atmosphere. Evaluation of the anticancer activity of these complexes can be achieved by the MTT assay.
The MTT assay is a colorimetric viability assay based on enzymatic reduction of the MTT molecule to formazan when it is exposed to viable cells. The outcome of the reduction is a color change of the MTT molecule. Absorbance measurements relative to a control determine the percentage of remaining viable cancer cells following their treatment with varying concentrations of a tested compound, which is translated to the compound anticancer activity and its IC50 values. The MTT assay is widely common in cytotoxicity studies due to its accuracy, rapidity, and relative simplicity.
Herein we present a detailed protocol for the synthesis of air sensitive metal based drugs and cell viability measurements, including preparation of the cell plates, incubation of the compounds with the cells, viability measurements using the MTT assay, and determination of IC50 values.
Titanium (IV) and vanadium (V) complexes are highly potent anticancer agents. A challenge in their synthesis refers to their hydrolytic instability; therefore their preparation should be conducted under an inert atmosphere. Evaluation of the anticancer activity of these complexes can be achieved by the MTT assay.
The MTT assay is a colorimetric viability assay based on enzymatic reduction of the MTT molecule to formazan when it is exposed to viable cells. The outcome of the reduction is a color change of the MTT molecule. Absorbance measurements relative to a control determine the percentage of remaining viable cancer cells following their treatment with varying concentrations of a tested compound, which is translated to the compound anticancer activity and its IC50 values. The MTT assay is widely common in cytotoxicity studies due to its accuracy, rapidity, and relative simplicity.
Herein we present a detailed protocol for the synthesis of air sensitive metal based drugs and cell viability measurements, including preparation of the cell plates, incubation of the compounds with the cells, viability measurements using the MTT assay, and determination of IC50 values.