1. Design the FRET assay.
Figure 1: The crystal structure of Cul1•Cand1 and measurement of the distance between potential labeling sites. The crystal structure file was downloaded from Protein Data Bank (File 1U6G), and viewed in PyMOL. Measurements between selected atoms were done by PyMOL. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: The excitation and emission spectra of the fluorescent dyes for FRET. Spectra of AMC (7-amino-4-methylcoumarin) and FlAsH are shown. Dashed lines indicate excitation spectra, and solid lines indicate emission spectra. The image was originally generated by the Fluorescence SpectraViewer and was modified for better clarity. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
2. Preparation of Cul1AMC•Rbx1, the FRET donor protein
3. Preparation of FlAsHCand1, the FRET acceptor protein
NOTE: Most of steps in this part are the same as Step 2. Conditions that differ are described in detail below.
4. Preparation of Cand1, the FRET chase protein
NOTE: The protein preparation protocol is similar to Step 3, with the following modifications.
5. Test and confirm the FRET assay
6. Measure the association rate constant (kon) of Cul1•Cand1
NOTE: Details of operating a stopped-flow fluorimeter has been described in a previous report26.
7. Measure the dissociation rate constant (koff) of Cul1•Cand1 in the presence of Skp1•F-box protein.
NOTE: This step is similar to Step 6, with the following modifications.
To test the FRET between Cul1AMC and FlAsHCand1, we first determined the emission intensity of 70 nM Cul1AMC (the donor) and 70 nM FlAsHCand1 (the acceptor), respectively (Figure 3A-C, blue lines). In each analysis, only one emission peak was present, and the emission of FlAsHCand1 (the acceptor) was low. When 70 nM each of Cul1AMC and FlAsHCand1 were mixed to generate FRET, two emission peaks were present in the emission spectra, and the peak of Cul1AMC became lower and the peak of FlAsHCand1 became higher (Figure 3A-C, red lines). When the full-length Cand1 was used for FRET, the donor peak showed a 10% reduction in intensity (Figure 3A, red line), and when Cand1 with its first helix truncated was used, the reduction of donor peak intensity was increased to 30% (Figure 3B-D, red lines), suggesting higher FRET efficiency. To confirm that the signal changes were resulted from FRET between Cul1AMC and FlAsHCand1, 70 nM Cul1AMC (the donor) was mixed with 700 nM unlabeled Cand1 (the chase) and 70 nM FlAsHCand1 (the acceptor). As a result, the donor peak was fully restored and the acceptor peak was decreased (Figure 3C, green line), which confirmed that the observed FRET depends on the formation of the Cul1AMC•FlAsHCand1 complex. Adding 700 nM Skp1•Skp2 to the 70 nM Cul1AMC•FlAsHCand1 also fully restored the donor peak (Figure 3D, green line), suggesting that the Cul1•Cand1 complex was fully disrupted by Skp1•Skp2 at equilibrium.
Figure 3: Representative FRET assay for Cul1•Cand1 complex formation. Samples in the FRET buffer (30 mM Tris-HCl, 100 mM NaCl, 0.5 mM DTT, 1 mg/mL ovalbumin, pH 7.6) were excited at 350 nm, and the emissions were scanned from 400 nm to 650 nm. (A) Emission spectra of 70 nM Cul1AMC, 70 nM FlAsHCand1 (full), and a mixture of the two (FRET). Cand1 (full) stands for full length Cand1. (B) Emission spectra of 70 nM Cul1AMC, 70 nM FlAsHCand1, and a mixture of the two (FRET). Cand1 with its first helix deleted was used in this experiment and thereafter. (C) Emission spectra of 70 nM Cul1AMC, 70 nM FlAsHCand1, a mixture of the two (FRET), and chase control for FRET (Chase). The chase sample contained 70 nM Cul1AMC, 700 nM Cand1 and 70 nM FlAsHCand1. (D) Emission spectra of 70 nM Cul1AMC, a mixture of 70 nM Cul1AMC and 70 nM FlAsHCand1 (FRET), and 700 nM Skp1•Skp2 added to the 70 nM Cul1AMC•FlAsHCand1 complex. In each plot, the emission signals were normalized to the emission of 70 nM Cul1AMC at 450 nm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
To measure the kon of Cul1•Cand1 using the established FRET assay by monitoring the reduction of the donor signal over time on the stopped-flow fluorimeter, we first tested and determined the concentration of the protein to be used. When 5 nM each of Cul1AMC and FlAsHCand1 were used, very little signal change was observed (Figure 4A), whereas, when the concentration of each protein was increased to 50 nM, the reduction of the signal over time was observed (Figure 4B) and this change was abolished if buffer without FlAsHCand1 was added (Figure 4C). Therefore, 50 nM Cul1AMC was used for further analyses, and a series of observed association rate constants (kobs) were measured by mixing 50 nM Cul1AMC with increasing concentrations of FlAsHCand1. The kobs for each experiment was calculated by fitting the points to a single exponential curve, and the kobs obtained from the same FlAsHCand1 concentration were averaged. By plotting the average kobs with the Cand1 concentration and performing a linear regression (Figure 4D), the kon was determined7,27.
Figure 4: Representative measurement of association rate constant. (A) The fluorescence of 5 nM Cul1AMC was monitored by a stopped-flow fluorimeter over time upon addition of 5 nM FlAsHCand1. (B) The fluorescence of 50 nM Cul1AMC was monitored by a stopped-flow fluorimeter over time upon addition of 50 nM FlAsHCand1. (C) The fluorescence of 50 nM Cul1AMC was monitored by a stopped-flow fluorimeter over time upon addition of the FRET buffer. (D) kon for Cand1 binding to Cul1. kobs of Cul1•Cand1 at different concentrations of Cand1 are plotted. Linear slope gives kon of 1.8 x 107 M-1 s-1. Error bars represent ±SEM; n = 4. All samples were prepared in the FRET buffer and excited at 350 nm. A band-pass filter was used to collect signals from AMC and exclude signals from FlAsH. No data were normalized. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Similar to the measurement of kon, we measured the observed dissociation rate constant of Cul1•Cand1 by monitoring the increase (restore) of the donor signal over time on the stopped-flow fluorimeter. Cul1AMC and FlAsHCand1 were mixed first, and then Skp1•Skp2 was added to the preassembled Cul1AMC•FlAsHCand1 on the stopped-flow fluorimeter. The donor signal increased quickly and it revealed a kobs of 0.4 s-1 (Figure 5). In contrast, when buffer was added to the preassembled Cul1AMC•FlAsHCand1, no signal increase was observed, suggesting the fast dissociation of Cul1•Cand1 was triggered by Skp1•Skp2.
Figure 5: Representative measurement of dissociation rate constant. The change in donor fluorescence versus time was measured following addition of 150 nM Skp1•Skp2 or the FRET buffer to 50 nM Cul1AMC•FlAsHCand1 complex. Signal changes were fit to a single exponential curve, and it gives observed dissociation rate constant of 0.4 s-1. The experimental conditions were similar to that described in Figure 4. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Anion exchange chromatography column | GE Healthcare | 17505301 | HiTrap Q FF anion exchange chromatography column |
Benchtop refrigerated centrifuge | Eppendorf | 2231000511 | |
BL21 (DE3) Competent Cells | ThermoFisher Scientific | C600003 | |
Calcium Chloride | Fisher Scientific | C78-500 | |
Cation exchange chromatography column | GE Healthcare | 17505401 | HiTrap SP Sepharose FF |
Desalting Column | GE Healthcare | 17085101 | |
Floor model centrifuge (high speed) | Beckman Coulter | J2-MC | |
Floor model centrifuge (low speed) | Beckman Coulter | J6-MI | |
Fluorescence SpectraViewer | ThermoFisher Scientific | https://www.thermofisher.com/us/en/home/life-science/cell-analysis/labeling-chemistry/fluorescence-spectraviewer.html | |
FluoroMax fluorimeter | HORIBA | FluoroMax-3 | |
FPLC | GE Healthcare | 29018224 | |
GGGGAMC peptide | New England Peptide | custom synthesis | |
Glutathione beads | GE Healthcare | 17075605 | |
Glycerol | Fisher Scientific | G33-500 | |
HEPES | Fisher Scientific | BP310-100 | |
Isopropyl-β-D-thiogalactoside (IPTG) | Fisher Scientific | 15-529-019 | |
LB Broth | Fisher Scientific | BP1426-500 | |
Ni-NTA agarose | Qiagen | 30210 | |
Ovalbumin | MilliporeSigma | A2512 | |
pGEX-4T-2 vector | GE Healthcare | 28954550 | |
Protease inhibitor cocktail | MilliporeSigma | 4693132001 | |
Reduced glutathione | Fisher Scientific | BP25211 | |
Refrigerated shaker | Eppendorf | M1282-0004 | |
Rosetta Competent Cells | MilliporeSigma | 70953-3 | |
Size exclusion chromatography column | GE Healthcare | 28990944 | Superdex 200 10/300 GL column |
Sodium Chloride (NaCl) | Fisher Scientific | S271-500 | |
Stopped-flow fluorimeter | Hi-Tech Scientific | SF-61 DX2 | |
TCEP·HCl | Fisher Scientific | PI20490 | |
Thrombin | MilliporeSigma | T4648 | |
Tris Base | Fisher Scientific | BP152-500 | |
Ultrafiltration membrane | MilliporeSigma | UFC903008 | Amicon Ultra-15 Centrifugal Filter Units, Ultra-15, 30,000 NMWL |
Proteins are the primary operators of biological systems, and they usually interact with other macro- or small molecules to carry out their biological functions. Such interactions can be highly dynamic, meaning the interacting subunits are constantly associated and dissociated at certain rates. While measuring the binding affinity using techniques such as quantitative pull-down reveals the strength of the interaction, studying the binding kinetics provides insights on how fast the interaction occurs and how long each complex can exist. Furthermore, measuring the kinetics of an interaction in the presence of an additional factor, such as a protein exchange factor or a drug, helps reveal the mechanism by which the interaction is regulated by the other factor, providing important knowledge for the advancement of biological and medical research. Here, we describe a protocol for measuring the binding kinetics of a protein complex that has a high intrinsic association rate and can be dissociated quickly by another protein. The method uses fluorescence resonance energy transfer to report the formation of the protein complex in vitro, and it enables monitoring the fast association and dissociation of the complex in real time on a stopped-flow fluorimeter. Using this assay, the association and dissociation rate constants of the protein complex are quantified.
Proteins are the primary operators of biological systems, and they usually interact with other macro- or small molecules to carry out their biological functions. Such interactions can be highly dynamic, meaning the interacting subunits are constantly associated and dissociated at certain rates. While measuring the binding affinity using techniques such as quantitative pull-down reveals the strength of the interaction, studying the binding kinetics provides insights on how fast the interaction occurs and how long each complex can exist. Furthermore, measuring the kinetics of an interaction in the presence of an additional factor, such as a protein exchange factor or a drug, helps reveal the mechanism by which the interaction is regulated by the other factor, providing important knowledge for the advancement of biological and medical research. Here, we describe a protocol for measuring the binding kinetics of a protein complex that has a high intrinsic association rate and can be dissociated quickly by another protein. The method uses fluorescence resonance energy transfer to report the formation of the protein complex in vitro, and it enables monitoring the fast association and dissociation of the complex in real time on a stopped-flow fluorimeter. Using this assay, the association and dissociation rate constants of the protein complex are quantified.
Proteins are the primary operators of biological systems, and they usually interact with other macro- or small molecules to carry out their biological functions. Such interactions can be highly dynamic, meaning the interacting subunits are constantly associated and dissociated at certain rates. While measuring the binding affinity using techniques such as quantitative pull-down reveals the strength of the interaction, studying the binding kinetics provides insights on how fast the interaction occurs and how long each complex can exist. Furthermore, measuring the kinetics of an interaction in the presence of an additional factor, such as a protein exchange factor or a drug, helps reveal the mechanism by which the interaction is regulated by the other factor, providing important knowledge for the advancement of biological and medical research. Here, we describe a protocol for measuring the binding kinetics of a protein complex that has a high intrinsic association rate and can be dissociated quickly by another protein. The method uses fluorescence resonance energy transfer to report the formation of the protein complex in vitro, and it enables monitoring the fast association and dissociation of the complex in real time on a stopped-flow fluorimeter. Using this assay, the association and dissociation rate constants of the protein complex are quantified.