Here we present a protocol to describe the development and validation of a single molecule array digital ELISA assay, which enables the ultra-sensitive detection of all IFN-α subtypes in human samples.
The main aim of this protocol is to describe the development and validation of an interferon (IFN)-α single molecule array digital Enzyme-Linked ImmunoSorbent Assay (ELISA) assay. This system enables the quantification of human IFN-α protein with unprecedented sensitivity, and with no cross-reactivity for other species of IFN.
The first key step of the protocol is the choice of the antibody pair, followed by the conjugation of the capture antibody to paramagnetic beads, and biotinylation of the detection antibody. Following this step, different parameters such as assay configuration, detector antibody concentration, and buffer composition can be modified until optimum sensitivity is achieved. Finally, specificity and reproducibility of the method are assessed to ensure confidence in the results. Here, we developed an IFN-α single molecule array assay with a limit of detection of 0.69 fg/mL using high-affinity autoantibodies isolated from patients with biallelic mutations in the autoimmune regulator (AIRE) protein causing autoimmune polyendocrinopathy syndrome type 1/autoimmune polyendocrinopathy-candidiasis-ectodermal dystrophy (APS1/APECED). Importantly, these antibodies enabled detection of all 13 IFN-α subtypes.
This new methodology allows the detection and quantification of IFN-α protein in human biological samples at attomolar concentrations for the first time. Such a tool will be highly useful in monitoring the levels of this cytokine in human health and disease states, most particularly infection, autoimmunity, and autoinflammation.
Type I IFNs are a family of cytokines which play a central role in orchestrating antiviral immune responses. They were first discovered by Isaacs and Lindenmann 60 years ago1,2 and it is now known that this heterogeneous family of polypeptides comprises 14 different subclasses (13 IFN-α subtypes and 1 IFN-β). Type I IFNs are essential to the clearance of viral infections, but have also been implicated in the pathology of a variety of human disease states, including the autoimmune disorders systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), juvenile dermatomyositis (JDM), and the type I interferonopathies in which constitutive type I IFN-induced signaling results in pathology3,4,5,6,7.
Studying type I IFN protein levels in biological samples has been challenging since its initial identification as an "interfering substance"1,2. Currently, sandwich Enzyme-Linked ImmunoSorbent Assay (ELISA) is the most widely used method for detection of IFN-α protein. Despite being specific, simple, and rapid, type I IFN ELISAs present important limitations, such as limited sensitivity. In addition, the measurement of all IFN-α subtypes requires the use of multiple assays each with their own detection capacity and sensitivity. While there are commercial ELISAs that detect different subtypes of IFN-α, their sensitivity is limited (1.95 pg/mL, 12.5 pg/mL, and 12.5 pg/mL, respectively) which is often insufficient to detect IFN-α protein in biological samples. To overcome this limitation, several biological proxy assays have been developed to quantify type I IFN by measuring induced gene expression or functional activity8,9,10,11,12,13,14. Nonetheless, these assays do not provide a direct measurement of the IFN-α protein.
In this study, single molecule array digital ELISA technology was used to develop an assay for the detection of single IFN-α protein molecules. Digital ELISA utilizes the same basic chemistry as conventional ELISA, however, the reaction takes place in arrays comprising 50,000 individual 46 femtoliter sized wells15,16. Single protein molecules are captured by antibody-coated paramagnetic beads and labeled with a biotinylated detection antibody, followed by binding of an enzyme conjugate, streptavidin-β-galactosidase (SBG). Subsequently, the beads are suspended with a fluorogenic enzyme substrate, resorufin-β-D-galactopyranoside (RGP), into single-molecule arrays. By decreasing the volume reaction 2 billion times17, a high local concentration of fluorescent signal is achieved and single molecule counts become feasible, as each molecule generates a signal that can now be reliably measured18. In essence single molecule arrays are capable of counting single immunocomplexes and determining an average number of enzymes per bead (AEB). Counting the microwells in which a signal is detected permits quantification/digitalization of protein molecules, as there is a direct correlation between protein concentration and the ratio between immunocomplexed-beads and a total number of beads present in the femtoliter-sized chambers.
Yeung et al. performed an extensive cross-platform evaluation study using nine different technologies and four cytokine immunoassays with the aim of comparing assay precision, sensitivity, and data correlation across the different platforms19. One of the key findings of the study was that single molecule arrays and single molecule counting immunoassay presented the highest sensitivity for detection of cytokines in human serum within the sub-pg/mL concentration range. Single molecule array digital ELISA cytokine assays have been used to study the role of TNF-α and IL-6 in Crohn's disease20, IFN-α in interferonopathy and auto-immune patients 7, and the different post-translationally modified forms of C-X-C motif chemokine 10 (CXCL10) in chronic hepatitis and healthy donors receiving sitagliptin21,22. Other applications include measurement of rhodopsin in patients with diabetic retinopathy23; the study of brain pathologies through serum/plasma measurements of neurofilament light24 and amyloid-β 1-42 peptide25, in the context of multiple sclerosis and Alzheimer's disease, respectively. Single molecule array assays can also be used for improved pathogen detection such as characterization of the HIV viral reservoir26, and also for detection of DNA27 and micro RNAs28. A major advantage of the single molecule array technology is this high versatility, as an assay against any analyte of interest can be developed if a specific antibody pair is available. In addition, homebrew assay kits are commercially available, allowing the development of new assays, the protocol of which is detailed in a modified form below.
Here, a detailed description of the development and validation steps for a single molecule array assay is presented that results in enhanced sensitivity for IFN-α protein detection. Antibodies for single molecule array assays should be highly specific, avoiding cross reactivity with related proteins (with species specificity considered if relevant). Ideally, antibodies with a KD smaller than 10-9 M should be chosen; high affinity ensures strong binding, with the production of a higher signal. The kinetics of the antibody-antigen binding are also important, and fast Kon and slow Koff will favor antigen-antibody complex assembly. Starting with an antibody pair that has a good performance in classical ELISA, with a limit of detection (LOD) of 1 – 100 pg/mL, increases the chances of obtaining a highly sensitive single molecule array assay. Chang and colleagues performed detailed kinetic studies of the biomolecular interactions occurring at every single step, proposing a set of equations to predict analytical sensitivity18. They showed that single molecule array digital ELISA appears to be effective within a broad range of antibody affinities (KD~10−11 – 10−9 M), as well as that signal generation is more dependent on the on-rate of such antibodies.
To utilize high affinity antibodies we took advantage of antibodies isolated from patients with the autoimmune polyendocrinopathy syndrome type 1/autoimmune polyendocrinopathy-candidiasis-ectodermal dystrophy (APS1/APECED)29. For reasons that are not yet understood, the large majority of AIRE-deficient individuals develop a core set of high-avidity antibodies against all IFN-α subtypes29, and we selected two anti-IFN-α antibody clones of complementary binding affinities for the different IFN-α subtypes, as estimated by IC50 values. The combination of these unique high-affinity antibodies with single molecule array technology enabled the direct quantification of IFN-α at attomolar (fg/mL) concentrations. Such ultrasensitive IFN-α protein detection will contribute to a better understanding of the nature, regulation and biological impact of the IFN-induced response in different disease settings.
Herein, we described the development and validation of a highly reproducible, ultrasensitive single molecule array digital ELISA for direct quantification of IFN-α protein in human samples (steps summarized in Table 1). One of the most critical steps in the development of the assay is the choice of antibody pair16, with the characteristics in terms of kinetics and epitope binding being key to a successful assay. It is important to avoid the use of paired monoclonal antibodies that target the same epitope or that cause steric impediment. Polyclonal antibodies could be used as detection antibodies to overcome such limitations. If at any given step the desired sensitivity is not achieved, further optimization possibilities should be considered. This may include the use of alternative antibody pairs, changes in parameters such as protein type (e.g. BSA < casein), pH (6.0 – 8.5), ionic strength, buffering capacity (e.g. NaCl and phosphate concentrations), carrier beads, and/or presence of surfactants. A wide range of parameters con be optimized when developing a single molecule array assay. However, overall, conditions that give high signal:background ratios and minimal LODs are the ones preferred (see Figure 1, Figure 2, and Figure 3).
Regarding specificity, the IFN-α assay showed no cross reactivity for any other IFNs tested (β, γ, λ1, λ2, ω) (Figure 4a) and was capable of detecting all 13 IFN-α subtypes (Figure 4b). However, the assay showed a lower affinity for the IFN-α2 subtype, (Figure 4b and Supplementary Table 4). Interestingly, different sensitivities for the different classes of IFN-α2 (a, b, c) were also observed, which may be due to distinct manufacturing procedures or different amino acid sequences, as the IFN-α2 subtypes were obtained from different commercial suppliers. With this sole exception, all the IFN-α species gave very similar responses. The specificity of the assay was further demonstrated by pre-treatment of the samples with the anti-IFN-α A clone, which abrogated the signal (Figure 6 and Supplementary Table 6).
One of the main advantages of this technology is that any analyte of interest can potentially be targeted16. Furthermore, different biological specimens can be tested, such as serum, plasma, cerebrospinal fluid, cellular lysates, culture supernatants31 and even breath32. Usually, a 1:3 dilution of plasma is performed to avoid potential clogging of the single molecule array analyzer. However, the analyte of interest could be present at very low concentrations in the relevant biological sample and higher concentrations of sample might be required (depending on assay sensitivity)33. Although there is potential for multiplexing while maintaining good sensitivity34, it is a more challenging process and assays for measuring greater than 6 proteins within the same experiments have yet to be developed35.
The ability to detect and quantify cytokines and other biological relevant proteins at such low concentrations opens up a whole new range of applications33,36. It is well known that numerous proteins exert their effects even at very low concentrations, which up until now were below the limit of detection of the best ELISAs37. While other immunoassay technologies offer advantages over conventional ELISA19, we demonstrate here that single molecule array digital ELISA is a reproducible and robust platform for the ultrasensitive detection of low concentration cytokines in human samples. As such, this technology offers enormous potential for biomarker discovery and improved patient management of a wide range of diseases.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
DD and YJC acknowledge support from the ANR (Project IFNX, no. CE17001002) and ImmunoQure AG for providing monoclonal antibodies. We thank Brigitte Bader-Meunier, Nathalia Bellon, Christine Bodemer, Alex Belot, Isabelle Melki, and Pierre Quartier for providing clinical samples. YJC acknowledges the European Research Council (GA 309449: Fellowship to YJC), and a state subsidy managed by the National Research Agency (France) under the "Investments for the Future" program bearing the reference ANR-10-IAHU-01.
Anti-IFN-α antibody A (8H1 clone) | ImmunoQure AG | NA | Not commercially available |
Anti-IFN-α antibody B (12H5 clone) | ImmunoQure AG | NA | Not commercially available |
Anti-IFN-α antibody EBI-1 clone | eBioscience | BMS216C | |
Anti-IFN-α antibody BMS216BK clone | eBioscience | BMS216BK | Not an ELISA kit but bulk abs |
IFN α2c | eBioscience | BMS305 | OK |
IFN αI (17) | PBL | 11150-1 | |
IFN α2a | PBL | 11100-1 | |
IFN α2a | PeproTech | No longer available | |
IFN α2b | PBL | 11105-1 | |
IFN α1 | PBL | 11175-1 | |
IFN α4a (M1) | PBL | 11177-1 | |
IFN α4b (a4) | PBL | 11180-1 | |
IFN αB2 (a8) | PBL | 11115-1 | |
IFN αC (a10) | PBL | 11120-1 | |
IFN αD (a1) | PBL | 11125-1 | |
IFN αG (a5) | PBL | 11135-1 | |
IFN αF (a21) | PBL | 11130-1 | |
IFN αH2 (a14) | PBL | 11145-1 | |
IFN αJ1 (a7) | PBL | 11160-1 | |
IFN αK (a6) | PBL | 11165-1 | |
IFN αWA (a16) | PBL | 11190-1 | |
IFN λ1 | PeproTech | 300-02L | |
IFN λ2 | PeproTech | 300-02K | |
IFN ω | PeproTech | 300-02J | |
IFN β | PeproTech | 300-02BC | |
IFN γ | PeproTech | 300-02 | |
Anti-IFN-α ELISA | PBL | 41115.1 | |
96-well plates | Corning | 3904 | |
ISRE-Reporter | Qiagen | CCS-008L | |
Fu-GENE HD Transfection Reagent | Promega | E2311 | |
Opti-MEM Reduced Serum Mediuem | ThermoFischer Scientific | 31985062 | |
Dual-Luciferase Reporter assay | Promega | E1910 | |
Nonidet P40 Substitute | Sigma-Aldrich | 74385 | |
Spectrophotometer NanoDrop 1000 | Thermo Scientific | No longer available | |
Amicon micocentrifuge tubes – 0.5mL filtres | Merck Millipore | UFC505096 | |
Bead Conjugation Buffer | Quanterix | 102040 | Can not be ordered separately |
Non-Encoded Paramagnetic Beads | Quanterix | 101360 | |
Bead Wash Buffer | Quanterix | 102040 | Can not be ordered separately |
EDC | Fisher Scientific | 11844071 | |
Bead Blocking Buffer | Quanterix | 102040 | Can not be ordered separately |
Bead Diluent Buffer | Quanterix | 101362 | |
Detector and Sample Diluent | Quanterix | 101359 | |
Biotinylation Reaction Buffer | Quanterix | 102040 | Can not be ordered separately |
NHS-PEG4-Biotin | Fisher Scientific | 11891195 | |
diH2O | |||
Centrifuge for 1.7mL microcentrifuge tubes (Heraens Fresco 21 Centrifuge) | Thermo Scientific | 75002478 | |
Standard laboratory vortex mixer (MS2 Minishaker) | IKA | MS2 | |
Pipettes (10, 20, 200 and 1000 μl) | Thermo Scientific | ||
Tips (10, 20, 200 and 1000 μl) | Thermo Scientific | ||
1.7mL microcentrifuge tubes | Eppendorf | ||
Magnetic separator that accomodates 1.7mL microcentrifuge tubes (Life Technologies DynaMag-2) | ThermoFisher Scientific | 12321D | |
Mini benchtop centrifuge (Galaxy MinisStar) | VWR | 521-2844 | |
Mixer/Shaker (Eppendorf Thermomixer Comfort) | Eppendorf | ||
Single molecule array (Simoa) reagents | |||
SBG, Bead and Detector Barcode Labels | Quanterix | 101652 | |
15 mL Reagent Bottles | Quanterix | 102411 | |
Simoa specimen 96-well plates | Quanterix | 101457 | |
Simoa Discs | Quanterix | 100001 | |
Simoa 2.0 conductive Tips | Quanterix | 101726 | |
Simoa Cuvettes | Quanterix | 100803 | |
Simoa SBG Reagent | Quanterix | 102295 | |
Simoa RGP Reagent | Quanterix | 101736 | |
Simoa System Buffer 1 | Quanterix | 100486 | |
Simoa System Buffer 2 | Quanterix | 100487 | |
Sealing Oil | Quanterix | 100206 | |
ddH2O | |||
Simoa HD-1 Analyzer | Quanterix | 100032 | |
Technologies | |||
Single molecule array (Simoa) | Quanterix | ||
Single molecule counting Erenna Immunoassay Systems | Singluex |