Here we describe the detailed procedure of intestinal ischemia-reperfusion in mice which results in reproducible injury without mortality to encourage the standardization of this technique across the field. This model of intestinal ischemia-reperfusion injury can be utilized to study the cellular and molecular mechanisms of injury and regeneration.
Intestinal ischemia is a life-threatening condition associated with a broad range of clinical conditions including atherosclerosis, thrombosis, hypotension, necrotizing enterocolitis, bowel transplantation, trauma and chronic inflammation. Intestinal ischemia-reperfusion (IR) injury is a consequence of acute mesenteric ischemia, caused by inadequate blood flow through the mesenteric vessels, resulting in intestinal damage. Reperfusion following ischemia can further exacerbate damage of the intestine. The mechanisms of IR injury are complex and poorly understood. Therefore, experimental small animal models are critical for understanding the pathophysiology of IR injury and the development of novel therapies.
Here we describe a mouse model of acute intestinal IR injury that provides reproducible injury of the small intestine without mortality. This is achieved by inducing ischemia in the region of the distal ileum by temporally occluding the peripheral and terminal collateral branches of the superior mesenteric artery for 60 min using microvascular clips. Reperfusion for 1 hr, or 2 hr after injury results in reproducible injury of the intestine examined by histological analysis. Proper position of the microvascular clips is critical for the procedure. Therefore the video clip provides a detailed visual step-by-step description of this technique. This model of intestinal IR injury can be utilized to study the cellular and molecular mechanisms of injury and regeneration.
The intestine is very sensitive to interruption of blood flow which causes ischemia and epithelial damage. Reperfusion after ischemia provides re-oxygenation of the tissue, and can further promote pathology. Therefore, intestinal ischemia and reperfusion injury is associated with a wide range of pathologies, including necrotizing enterocolitis, allograft rejection in small bowel transplantation, complications of abdominal aortic aneurysm surgery, cardiopulmonary bypass, and inflammatory bowel disease 1,2. Intestinal IR injury, especially acute mesenteric ischemia, is a life threatening condition resulting in morbidity and mortality 3.
Although poorly understood, intestinal ischemia-reperfusion (IR) injury is thought to be associated with changes in the gut microbiota as well as the production of reactive oxygen species and inflammatory cytokines and chemokines 1,4-6. This leads to activation of both innate and adaptive immune mechanisms which promote inflammation and tissue injury 1,7,8.
Animal models are critical for understanding the mechanisms of IR injury, as they allow easy gain- and loss-of-function genetic experiments. Several animal models of IR have been developed which include complete vascular occlusion, low flow ischemia, and segmented vascular occlusion (summarized in a recent comprehensive review 9). Intestinal ischemia caused by complete vascular occlusion of superior mesenteric artery (SMA) is an easy and commonly used model of IR in large animals and rodents 9-11. However, different areas of the gut have different susceptibility to injury. In addition, the diverse range of anesthetics, analgesics, artery occlusion techniques, as well as inconsistency in the duration of ischemic injury and recovery result in variable degrees of injury confounding our understanding of the biology of IR across multiple studies. Table 1 demonstrates these inconsistencies in murine IR studies. The biggest drawback from using shorter ischemic times (30-45 min) is targeting the window of recovery upon which discernible differences between cases and controls can be observed. Mild injury to the epithelium may be resolved an hour after reperfusion, therefore specialized pathological metrics may be required to find differences in epithelial restitution. In contrast, excessive damage, as seen by 100 min of ischemic injury may result in the complete denudement of the epithelium, where restitution is no longer possible, increasing the rate of mortality, and recovery time. Therefore, here we describe the detailed procedure of intestinal IR in mice which results in reproducible injury without mortality to encourage the standardization of this technique across our field. This model of intestinal IR injury can be utilized to study the cellular and molecular mechanisms of injury and regeneration.
Animal studies were performed in accordance with the National Institute of Health guidelines and were approved by the Institutional Animal Care and use Committee of the Trudeau Institute. 8-12 week old C57BL/6 mice were used for the study.
1. Preparation for Surgery
2. Anesthesia
3. Surgery
4. Reperfusion Stage
5. Necropsy and Harvesting of Small Intestine
6. Scoring
We optimized the experimental protocol of IR surgery to obtain reproducible IR induced injury of the ileum in mice. Representative results are demonstrated in this section.
Figure 1 shows examples of microvascular clips position to induce ischemia of the ileum. Black arrows show position of the main clips occluding first order branches of superior mesenteric artery. Green arrows show the position of additional clips to block blood supply from collateral vessels. Note increased size of occluded vessels distal to the clips position and color change of the ischemic region of intestinte. After removal of the clips at the end of ischemia blood vessels regain blood flow and return to normal size.
Figure 2 shows an example of a tissue cassette containing Swiss rolls prepared from control and ischemic regions of the ileum after 1 hr of ischemia, followed by a 1 hr of reperfusion. A piece of spleen was included to facilitate positioning of control and IR intestine during processing and staining. Note the color difference between control and ischemic tissue.
Figure 3 shows representative hematoxylin and eosin staining of control and ischemic regions of the ileum after 1 hr of ischemia, or 1 hr of ischemia followed by a 2 hr of reperfusion. Note the severe damage of the epithelium after 1 hr of ischemia characterized by hemorrhagic villi, epithelium denudement with partial to complete ablation of crypts, and immune cell infiltration (asterisk). After a 2 hr of reperfusion villi damage and inflammation persist (asterisk), but there is no tissue hemorrhage.
Figure 4 shows an example of the analysis of inflammatory cytokines expression at 1 hr and 2 hr after ischemia-reperfusion in ischemic and control intestine. Note upregulation of mRNA expression of TNF, IL-1b, IL-6 and CXCL2 at 1 hr and 2 hr after ischemia-reperfusion compared to control healthy tissue.
Figure 1: Induction of Ischemia using Vascular Clips. (A) Isolated area of the intestine containing cecum and ileum. Small cuts in the mesentery surrounding the superior mesenteric artery are made to facilitate clip application. (B) Microvascular clip application using clip applier. (C) Position of microvascular clips on superior mesenteric artery to induce ischemia. (D, E). Examples of vasculature structure and clip positioning in different mice. Arrows indicate the ischemic area of ileum marked by hematoxylin. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Tissue Preparation for Histological Analysis. Tissue cassette containing Swiss rolls prepared from ischemic and control regions of the ileum after 1 hr of ischemia followed by a 1 hr of reperfusion. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Hematoxylin and Eosin Staining of Ileum after Ischemia. Hematoxylin and eosin staining of control and ischemic regions of the ileum after 1 hr of ischemia, or 1 hr of ischemia followed by a 2 hr of reperfusion. Bars = 500 μm (top panels), 200 μm (bottom panels). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Expression of Inflammatory Cytokines During Ischemia-Reperfusion. Expression of CXCL2, TNF, IL-6, IL-1b was measured at 1 hr and 2 hr after ischemia-reperfusion in ischemic tissue (IR) and normal control tissue (C) adjacent to the ischemic region by real-time PCR. n = 3 – 8 mice per group, * p <0.05; ** p <0.01; *** p <0.001. Error bars represent s.e.m. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Murine Species | Anesthesia / Analgesia | Artery occlusion method | Ischemia time | Time after reperfusion | Reference | |||
Sprague-Dawley rats | Sodium pentobarbital | Occlusion of SMA and celiac artery using aneurysm clip or clamp | 45 min | 2 hr | 12 | |||
C57Bl6/129 | 2% halothane | Occlusion of mesenteric arteriole, and the proximal and distal portions of the ischemic tissue. | 30 to 130 min | 6 hr | 13 | |||
C57BL/6 | Ketamine, Isoflurane | Occlusion of SMA using aneurysm clips. Occlusion of collateral circulation at the proximal and distal areas. | 1 hr | 1.5 hr | 4,8,11 | |||
C3H/Hej | Sodium pentobarbital | Occlusion using aneurysm clip or clamp | 40 min | 6 hr | 14 | |||
C56BL/6 | Isoflurane | Occlusion of SMA and ileocolic artery using aneurysm clip or clamp | 100 min | 1, 2, 4, 24 hr | 15 | |||
C57BL/6 | Urethane | Occlusion using aneurysm clip or clamp | 45 min | 60 min | 16 |
Table 1: Variations in Methodology in Murine Intestinal IR-induced Injury
Histology scoring system | Reference | ||
Grade 0: Normal mucosa | 13,17,18 | ||
Grade 1: Subepithelial space at the villous tip | |||
Grade 2: More extended subepithelial space | |||
Grade 3: Epithelial lifting along the villous sides | |||
Grade 4: Denuded villi | |||
Grade 5: Loss of villous tissue | |||
Grade 6: Crypt layer infarction | |||
Grade 7: Transmucosal infarction | |||
Grade 8: Transmural infarction | |||
Grade 0: Normal mucosa | 4,8,11,19-21 | ||
Grade 1: Sloughing of cells on villous tips | |||
Grade 2: Mid-villous damage | |||
Grade 3: Villi were absent, but crypts were still readily detectable | |||
Grade 4: Complete absence of epithelial structures and transmural necrosis | |||
Grade 0: Normal villus | 6,22-31 | ||
Grade 1: Villi with tip distortion | |||
Grade 2: Goblet cells and Gugenheims' spaces are missing | |||
Grade 3: Villi with patchy disruption of the epithelial cells | |||
Grade 4: Villi with exposed, but intact lamina propria with epithelial cell sloughing | |||
Grade 5: Lamina propria is exuding | |||
Grade 6: Villi that display hemorrhage or to villi that are denuded | |||
Grade 0: Normal histology | 32,33 | ||
Grade 1: Slight disruption of the surface epithelium | |||
Grade 2: Epithelial cell loss injury at villus tip | |||
Grade 3: Mucosal vasocongestion, hemorrhage, and focal necrosis with loss of less than half of villi | |||
Grade 4: Damage extending to more than one-half of villi |
Table 2: Histology Scoring Systems in Murine Intestinal IR-induced Injury
The development of mouse models of intestinal IR injury have greatly improved the understanding of the mechanisms of tissue injury and aided in the development of potential therapeutic strategies to minimize tissue damage 7,9,11,34. The critical steps of this protocol are proper positioning of the microvascular clips, correct timing of the ischemia and proper histologic evaluation of IR injury.
The duration of ischemia is critical for subsequent epithelial damage. The typical time required to induce reproducible IR injury without morbidity and mortality of experimental mice is 45-60 min followed by a 2-3 hr reperfusion. Extended periods of ischemia may results in complete loss of the epithelium and increased mortality. For example, in a porcine model of jejunal ischemia, 60 min occlusion resulted in partial loss of villa epithelium, whereas occlusion for 120 min led to the complete loss of villus epithelium 35. Importantly, germ-free and genetically manipulated mice may display an increased sensitivity to IR injury, and therefore optimal time of ischemia and reperfusion may need to be optimized in preliminary experiments. Although typical time for evaluation of tissue damage after reperfusion is 2-3 hr, longer time (12 hr) is required for the analysis of intestinal stem cell mobilization 36. Additionally, changes in commensal microbiota and TLR/Nod-mediated signaling can significantly influence the outcome of the of IR injury 4,8,37-39.
The proper position of microvascular clips is also critical for reproducible IR injury. Here we describe the model of IR injury of the murine distal ileum. Distinct parts of the intestine are known to display different sensitivity to IR injury. For example, jejunum is more sensitive to IR injury than ileum and colon 9,34,40. In fact, ischemia-reperfusion model of jejunum by occluding SMA with a single clip is commonly used to study the mechanisms of IR injury (see ref. 9 for a comprehensive review of different methods of IR-injury in animals). However, the precise position of the clip and the analysis of different sections of intestine, as well as different methods of anesthesia varies between these studies, making it difficult to reproduce (see Table 1). An additional complication of IR injury of jejunum is high mortality since position of the vascular clip close to the root of SMA affects blood supply to broad area of intestine. Therefore, in the current study we developed a protocol to induce consistent IR injury of terminal ileum, which is easy to reproduce. To induce reproducible IR injury of ileum, the proper position of vascular clips is critical. This is achieved by occluding the peripheral and collateral branches of the superior mesenteric artery.The degree of IR injury can be assessed by evaluation of hematoxylin and eosin sections using original Chiu/Park or modified score systems 11,18,34,41,42. Additionally, evaluation of tissue damage can be performed using terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase biotin-dUTP nick end-labeling (TUNEL) staining of fragmented DNA, or active caspase-3 immunohistochemical staining, analysis of neutrophils by measuring myeloperoxidase activity or immunohistochemical evaluation of neutrophils using Gr-1, or Ly6G antibody staining 7,11. Inflammatory cytokines and chemokines, such as IL-1b, TNF, IL-6, CXCL1, CXCL2, CCL2 can be evaluated by real-time PCR 2,4,8. An example of the analysis of inflammatory cytokine expression is shown on Figure 4.
It is important to note that despite the high reproducibility and accessibility of IR injury of the ileum, this model may not reflect all clinical signs of human disease, in particularly chronic disease conditions and conditions with partial occlusion of the superior mesenteric artery 9. There are also differences in villus microvasculature between mice and humans, as well as levels of xanthine oxidase, a key enzyme mediating production of reactive oxygen species during IR injury 9,43. Therefore, models using large animals, such as pigs are being developed 9,44. Careful selection of the animal model depending on the human condition being studied is critical. In summary, we describe an easy and robust model of intestinal IR injury which can be utilized to study the cellular and molecular mechanism of epithelial injury and regeneration.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by Russian Science Foundation, grant no. 14-50-00060 and LLC RUSCHEMBIO. This work was also supported by the Crohn`s and Colitis Foundation of America grant 294083 (to A.V.T.), and by NIH grant RO1 DK47700 (to C.J.).
Heated Pad | Sunbeam | E12107-819 | Alternative: Braintree Scientific heated pad |
Table top research anesthesia Machine | Vasco | UCAP 0001-0000171 | Alternative: Parkland Scientific, V3000PS |
Nose Cone | Parkland Scientific | ARES500 | |
Scavenger canister and replacement cartridge | Parkland Scientific | 80000, 80120 | |
Induction Chamber | Surgivet | V711802 | |
Isoflurane | Piramal Healthcare | NDC 66794-013-10 | Controlled substance, contact IACUC |
Animal clipper | Oster | Oster Golden A5 078005-050-003 | |
Ophthalmic ointment | Webster | 8804604 | |
Buprenorphine | McKesson | 562766 | Controlled substance,contact IACUC |
Ketaset (Ketamine HCl) | Pfizer | NADA 45-290 | Controlled substance, contact IACUC |
Cotton tips | Puritan medical products | 806-WC | Autoclave before use |
Betadine | Purdue Products | 67618-150-17 | 10% Povidone-Iodine |
Sterile saline solution | Aspen | 46066-807-60 | Adjust to room temperature before use |
Sterile cotton gauze pad | Fisher Healthcare | 22-415-468 | |
Non-adherent pad prepack | Telfa | 1238 | |
IR rodent thermometer | BIOSEB | BIO-IRB153 | |
Micro vascular clips, 70g | Roboz Surgical | RS5424, RS5435 | Alternative: WPI 14121, for SMA occlusion |
Micro vascular clips, 40g | Roboz Surgical | RS6472 | Alternative:WPI 14120, for collateral vessels occlusion |
Clip applying forceps | World Precision Instruments | 14189 | Alternative: Roboz #RS-5410 or #RS-5440 |
Gill's 3 hematoxylin | Thermo Scientific | 14-390-17 | |
Surgical staples, Reflex 9 mm | Cell Point Scientific | 201-1000 | |
Autoclip applier | Beckton Dickinson | 427630 | |
Byopsy foam pad | Simport | M476-1 | |
Tissue cassette | Fisher Healthcare | 15182701A | Histosette II combination lid and base |
10% buffered formalin | Fisher Scientific | 245-684 | |
Surgical iris scissors | World Precision Instruments | 501263-G SC | Alternative: Roboz RS6816 |
Operating scissors | World Precision Instruments | 501219-G | Alternative: Roboz RS6814 |
Dressing forceps | Roboz Surgical | RS-5228, RS-8122 | Alternative: World Precision Instruments 1519-G |
Heparin, endotoxin free, 300 USP units/vial, 50mg | Sigma | 2106 | |
Reflex wound clip removing forceps | Roboz Surgical | RS-9263 | Alternative: World Precision Instruments: 500347 |
Mice C57BL/6J mice | Jackson Laboratory | Stock No 0664 | |
Telfa non-adherent dressings, 3×4, sterile | Coviden | 1050 |