On-Chip Crystallization and Large-Scale Serial Diffraction at Room Temperature

Summary

This contribution describes how to set up protein crystallization on crystal-on-crystal devices and how to perform automated serial data collection at room temperature using the on-chip crystallization platform.

Abstract

Biochemical reactions and biological processes can be best understood by demonstrating how proteins transition among their functional states. Since cryogenic temperatures are non-physiological and may prevent, deter, or even alter protein structural dynamics, a robust method for routine X-ray diffraction experiments at room temperature is highly desirable. The crystal-on-crystal device and its accompanying hardware and software used in this protocol are designed to enable in situ X-ray diffraction at room temperature for protein crystals of different sizes without any sample manipulation. Here we present the protocols for the key steps from device assembly, on-chip crystallization, optical scanning, crystal recognition to X-ray shot planning and automated data collection. Since this platform requires no crystal harvesting nor any other sample manipulation, hundreds to thousands of protein crystals grown on chip can be introduced into an X-ray beam in a programmable and high-throughput manner.

Introduction

Due to the ionizing effects of X-ray radiation, protein crystallography, to a great extent, has been limited to cryogenic conditions in the last three decades. Therefore, the current knowledge of protein motions during its function largely arises from comparisons between static structures observed in different states under cryogenic conditions. However, cryogenic temperatures inevitably hinder the progression of a biochemical reaction or interconversion between different conformational states while protein molecules are at work. To directly observe protein structural dynamics at atomic resolution by crystallography, robust and routine methods are needed for conducting diffraction experiments at room temperature, which calls for technical innovations in sample delivery, data collection, and posterior data analysis. To this end, recent advances in serial crystallography have offered new avenues to capture the molecular images of intermediates and short-lived structural species at room temperature^1,2,3. In contrast to the "one-crystal-one-dataset" strategy widely used in conventional cryocrystallography, serial crystallography adopts a data collection strategy similar to that of single-particle cryo-electron microscopy. Specifically, the experimental data in serial crystallography are collected in small fractions from a large number of individual samples, followed by intensive data processing in which data fractions are evaluated and combined into a complete dataset for 3D structure determination⁴. This "one-crystal-one-shot" strategy effectively eases the X-ray radiation damage to protein crystals at room temperature via a diffraction before destruction strategy⁵.

Since serial crystallography requires a large number of protein crystals to complete a dataset, it poses major technical challenges for many biological systems where protein samples are limited and/or delicate crystal handling is involved. Another important consideration is how to best preserve crystal integrity in serial diffraction experiments. The in situ diffraction methods address these concerns by allowing protein crystals to diffract directly from where they grow without breaking the seal of the crystallization chamber^6,7,8,9. These handling-free methods are naturally compatible with large-scale serial diffraction. We have recently reported the design and implementation of a crystallization device for in situ diffraction based on a crystal-on-crystal concept – protein crystals grown directly on monocrystalline quartz¹¹. This "crystal-on-crystal" device offers several advantages. First, it features an X-ray and light transparent window made of a monocrystalline quartz substrate, which produces little background scattering, hence resulting in excellent signal-to-noise ratios in diffraction images from protein crystals. Second, the single-crystal quartz is an excellent vapor barrier equivalent to glass, thereby providing a stable environment for protein crystallization. In contrast, other crystallization devices using polymer-based substrates are prone to drying due to vapor permeability unless the polymer material has a substantial thickness, which consequently contributes to high background scattering¹⁰. Third, this device enables the delivery of a large number of protein crystals to the X-ray beam without any form of crystal manipulation or harvesting, which is critical for preserving crystal integrity¹¹.

To streamline serial X-ray diffraction experiments using the crystal-on-crystal devices, we have developed a diffractometer prototype to facilitate easy switching between the optical scanning and X-ray diffraction modes¹². This diffractometer has a small footprint and has been used for serial data collection at two beamlines of the Advanced Photon Source (APS) at Argonne National Laboratory. Specifically, we used BioCARS 14-ID-B for Laue diffraction and LS-CAT 21-ID-D for monochromatic oscillation. This diffractometer hardware is not required if a synchrotron or X-ray free-electron laser beamline is equipped with two key capabilities: (1) motorized sample positioning with a travel range of ±12 mm around the X-ray beam in all directions; and (2) an on-axis digital camera for crystal viewing under light illumination that is safe to protein crystals under study. The monocrystalline quartz device together with a portable diffractometer and the control software for optical scanning, crystal recognition, and automated in situ data collection collectively constitute the inSituX platform for serial crystallography. Although this development is primarily motivated by its dynamic crystallography applications using a polychromatic X-ray source, we have demonstrated the potential of this technology to support monochromatic oscillation methods^10,12. With automation, this platform offers a high-throughput serial data collection method at room temperature with affordable protein consumption.

In this contribution, we describe in detail how to set up on-chip crystallization in a wet lab and how to perform serial X-ray data collection at a synchrotron beamline using the inSituX platform.

The batch method is used to set up on-chip crystallization under a condition similar to that of the vapor diffusion method obtained for the same protein sample (Table 1). As a starting point, we recommend using precipitant at 1.2-1.5x concentration of that for the vapor diffusion method. If necessary, the batch crystallization condition can be further optimized via fine grid screening. Quartz wafers are not necessary for optimization trials; glass coverslips can be used instead (see below). Partially loaded crystallization devices are recommended to keep optimization trials on a smaller scale. A number of protein samples have been successfully crystallized on such devices using the batch method¹⁰ (Table 1).

The device itself consists of the following parts: 1) an outer ring; 2) two quartz wafers; 3) one washer-like shim of plastic or stainless steel; 4) a retaining ring; 5) microscope immersion oil as sealant (Figure 1). The total volume of the crystallization solution loaded on one chip depends on the purpose of the experiment. The capacity of the crystallization chamber can be adjusted by choosing a shim of different thicknesses and/or inner diameter. We routinely set up crystallization devices of 10-20 µL in capacity using shims of 50-100 μm in thickness. A typical device can produce tens to thousands of protein crystals adequate for serial data collection (Figure 2).

When successful, on-chip crystallization will produce tens to hundreds or even thousands of protein crystals on each quartz device ready for X-ray diffraction. At a synchrotron beamline, such a device is mounted on a three-axis translation stage of the diffractometer using a kinematic mechanism. The crystallization window of a mounted device is optically scanned and imaged in tens to hundreds of micrographs. These micrographs are then stitched into a high-resolution montage. For photosensitive crystals, optical scanning can be carried out under infrared (IR) light to avoid unintended photoactivation. A computer vision software has been developed to identify and locate protein crystals randomly distributed on the device. These crystals are then ranked according to their size, shape, and position to inform or guide the data collection strategy in serial crystallography. For example, single or multiple shots can be located on each targeted crystal. Users could plan a single pass or multiple routes through targeted crystals. We have implemented software to compute various traveling routes. For example, the shortest route is computed using algorithms that address the traveling salesman problem¹³. For pump-probe dynamic crystallographic applications, the timing and duration of laser (pump) and X-ray (probe) shots can be chosen. An automated serial data collection is programmed to translocate each targeted crystal into the X-ray beam one after another.

The key components of the insituX diffractometer include: 1) a device holder; 2) a three-axis translation stage; 3) a light source for optical scanning; 4) an X-ray beam stop; 5) pump lasers if light-sensitive proteins are studied; 6) Raspberry Pi microcomputer equipped with an IR-sensitive camera; 7) control software to synchronize motors, camera, light sources, pump laser, and to interface with beamline controls.

Protocol

1. Device pre-assembly Label the outer ring (30 mm diameter) for sample identification. If necessary, include the project name, device number, crystallization condition, and date (Figure 1A). Place the outer ring upside down on a clean surface (Figure 1B), and carefully place one quartz wafer inside the ring (Figure 1C). This first quartz wafer serves as an entrance window for the incident X-rays. …

Representative Results

Several representative datasets have been published In the past few years10,12 along with the crystallographic results and scientific findings from a diverse range of protein samples, including photoreceptor proteins and enzymes, for example, a plant UV-B photoreceptor UVR8, a light-driven DNA repair photolyase PhrB10, a novel far-red-light sensing protein from a multi-domain sensory histidine kinase14, ligand/light…

Discussion

Protein crystallography in the early years conducted at room temperature experienced tremendous difficulty in battling X-ray radiation damage. Thus, it has been superseded by the more robust cryocrystallography method as synchrotron X-ray sources became readily available²⁰. With the advent of X-ray free-electron lasers, room-temperature protein crystallography has been revived in recent years, with many new developments driven by a desire to observe protein structural dynamics at a physiologically…

Materials

Analysis software	In-house developed
Cerium doped yttrium aluminum garnet	MSE Supplies		Ce:Y3Al5O12, YAG single crystal substrates
Chip holder	In-house developed
Control software	In-house developed
Immersion oil	Cargille Laboratories	16482	Type A low viscosity 150 cSt
inSituX platform	In-house developed
IR light source	Thorlabs Incorporated	LED1085L	LED with a Glass Lens, 1085 nm, 5 mW, TO-18
Microscope	Zeiss		SteREO Discovery V8
Outer ring	In-house developed
Petri dish	Fisher Scietific	FB0875713
Pipette	Pipetman	F167380	P10
Pump lasers	Thorlabs Incorporated	LD785-SE400	785 nm, 400 mW, Ø9 mm, E Pin Code, Laser Diode
Raspberry Pi	Raspberry Pi Fundation
Retaining ring	Thorlabs Incorporated	SM1RR	SM1 retaining ring for Ø1" lens tubes and mounts
Seedless quartz crystal	University Wafers, Inc.	U01-W2-L-190514	25.4 mm diameter Z-cut 0.05 mm thickness double side polish 8 mm on -X
Shim	In-house developed
X-ray beam stop	In-house developed